"Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity...taken to its highest degree is the same thing as prayer"
Showing posts with label Asana-Pranayama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Asana-Pranayama. Show all posts

Thursday, November 7, 2019

sAdhanA – Looking In, Looking Out (Part 1)



In the philosophy and practice of Yoga, the words sAdhanA and abhyAsA are used almost interchangeably. In my swadhyaya, I recently saw and felt an expanded view of the idea of sAdhanA, a view that I have hitherto read about, appreciated, and tried to emulate in an intellectual way. 

One of my mentors blessed me after I recounted a particularly insightful and transforming meditative experience to her. Her blessing was “May this (experience) create a shift in your sAdhanA”.  Sometimes teachers and their words can be like clear mirrors that one can look into and catch a stunning sight of oneself. 

The flash of a question and a picture of sAdhanA arose in quick succession in that mirror.  The question in my mind had been, “oh, hasn’t the shift already happened? Wasn’t I doing my sAdhanA / abhyAsA with all that meditative practice?”  It was followed by a view of Practice or sAdhanA made up of seemingly discrete images and scenes from my own life, excerpts from stuff that I have read and stories I have been told, all coming together into one whole picture. I attempt here to draw that picture I seem to be holding.

The word sAdhanA is related to the following words in Hindi / Sanskrit:-
- sAdhan – a tool or instrument that helps us reach our goal,
- sAdhya – is like an achievement and / or possibility,
- sAdhaka – is the practitioner.

sAdhanA is a continued practice or discipline that is undertaken in pursuit of this goal. abhyAsA is a persistent and steady effort in one's practice. Both indicate that there is a direction of movement, while also having the quality of staying still with a pursuit / enquiry.  This dual quality is important to my meaning of practice. 

The ultimate journey and goal is to the truth within. This is like a theertha yatra that one undertakes – the big “who am I?” For, what is the truth within one is the most sacred of all things sacred, and the most mysterious of all mysteries, that philosophers, artists, writers, poets, dancers, and all spiritual seekers of all times have sought.

In this Yatra, I have been finding “me” at various times in different ways, at different levels and depths. One seemingly obvious truth that has hit me again and again with progressively harder impact until an extremely protective and hard shell layer cracked and shattered open, is that I can only be myself!  “Everyone else is already taken”.  (Someone has said this quoted phrase, I am not sure who). I have to nourish my unique beauty, as does each one.

It is only when I reach the real “me” inside, shattering years of hardened, comfortable notions, assumptions and beliefs about myself, can I meet the real other.  It is when I can see the ‘me’ who is behind many layers of the front-me that I can see the real person behind the other that I am trying to engage with and relate to. Their real desires and dreams underneath masks of politeness and propriety perhaps. Masks of cultural and other conditioning. The real fears, doubts and strengths.

My sAdhanA takes me continually to the more real Me and a more real world that I inhabit. However it cannot stop there.  Finding the real worldly me cannot be my purpose in this world. Finding this me is for getting to the purpose of my existence in this form. Of this I am now very sure.  It is through and while fulfilling this purpose that I can reach the ultimate Me that is the truth of all truths. In another lifetime.

In Yoga Therapy, especially in the Krishnamacharya Tradition which is my mother and father in Yoga therapy education and training, working with one’s Exhalation is given primary importance for healing and transformation. “It is exhalation that cures” is a statement I have heard often from my teachers.  The Elders say, “Inhalation takes care of itself. It is given by the Lord, the Universal Consciousness or Truth, and an extension of one’s Exhalation.  Make the Exhalation active and strong, and you will find the Inhalation also getting where it is meant to be.”

The Inhalation then is like the prasAdam (sanctified / consecrated gift) that we get after we serve our offerings to the Divine. I am sure this is also something one of my teachers must have said at some point, I don’t remember who or when.  The Inhalation is then all the gracious gifts that I receive from my world. I’m aware - just like that, in the blink of an eyelid, I have substituted the Divine with the world. This feels completely natural and a given for me. Must be the Vedantic upbringing and cultural atmosphere that I live in. Swami Vivekananda saw his Shiva in every being that he met, and served that Shiva (in his own words, Lectures from Colombo to Almora).  That is just one lived example and practice of the pantheistic understanding of my religion. 

The life that I receive is Inhalation. 

It then follows that the Exhalation is what I am offering to the world. What I give to the world around is like the Exhalation that I follow during my AsanA-prANAyAma practice.  I also wonder that there is a correlation between the quality of one’s Exhalation and the quality of one’s contribution in prANA exchange. (Every engagement in the world is an underlying exchange of prANA)

My sAdhanA on the mat is a practice of keen attention on the breath and body, which continuously takes me to a keen attention on where my attention is.

My sAdhanA off the mat is the keen attention I am able to offer to my world and the natural manifestations of that attention.

The spiritual practice that we call sAdhanA then does not stop with an individual, personal practice that I do with this limited ‘me’ that I can conceive of – limited by this body, my thoughts, emotions and breath.  It will include all that I do in the world outside, and even beyond to what my world is doing.  Every movement (physical, mental, emotional…) has to be infused with sAdhanA then for it to be worth its name (without making it into an injunction!).  And ‘my’ sAdhanA is not just mine. It is connected to everyone else’s.

The Yoga sutras talk of Bhava Pratyayas, people who are born in or experience and live in an exalted state of awareness, in a state of Yoga. Ramana Maharishi for example. These people don’t do, and don’t need to do an active sAdhanA as we understand it. Their very being is sAdhanA and if anything, they also undertake sAdhanA for the sake of healing and transformation of others. Their very presence is sAdhanA.

But for the rest of us, an active sAdhanA is prescribed by Patanjali in the Yoga sutras. And I realise that for me this includes all the work and everything else that I do, off my mat as well. And do, I must. This is part of my spiritual practice.  The keen inward attention during my personal practice, and the keen attention on matters of the world are like two polarities that I have to hold together, simultaneously. They make each other. Like Exhalation and Inhalation together make a breath.  Make life.

Someone like a Swami Vivekananda didn’t rest with his individual moksha. He served incessantly and achieved enormously in the public domain within the short life that he lived.  He talked some, and demonstrated much more, the interdependence and mutual existence of one’s inner journey and its outward, social manifestation. Gandhi’s life without a doubt was cut and woven together from the same spiritual cloth.  I recently read in an article by Pannalal Dasgupta about “this strange, Janus-like quality of Gandhiji – two faces looking in seemingly different directions.” 

This is the quality I believe my practice needs to strengthen.  It is the Practice. Of being able to look in and look out simultaneously without letting go of either.  For sAdhanA to come into its power, it needs to move out from the mat and change matter; Manifest as a coming together of the inner and outer journeys. And this is the meaning I give to the blessing I received from the mentor.  

Sunday, January 14, 2018

Reflections after Facilitating a Workshop in a Style Unique to Ritambhara*

Kaya Madhya Sutram (KMS), Tiruvannamalai, Jan 2018 - Reflections

Even while planning for the programme this time, I was planning with a lot of space. Usually I pack a lot in my planning and tagging several items in the sequence as ‘optional, if there is time’. This instance I straightaway noticed that my inclination was towards keeping the minimum required for it to be a KMS event. A vinyasa where each activity led to the next in natural logic. This actually gave me a lot of space to work in and flow and play and allow the same for others as well. I realised while planning and while executing, how much I have been cluttering my space with overplanning and overthinking. (I am not going into the roots of the overplanning and overthinking here, not within the scope now).  Without that clutter, the pressure for it to happen, and happen in a certain way was absent and I was completely aware of this. What freedom!

At the recent ECC (Exploring Contemplative Conversations) workshop, a reflection that came up in one of the early morning theatre sessions:  
I have never been able to feel Veeryam after any other Rasa but Roudram. I necessarily had to get in touch with Roudram in order to experience Veeryam.  Pre-planning and during KMS, for the first time, I was in a quieter space and a sense of courage and conviction that was flowing out of connection and quietness, manifesting in action at the event.  I am afraid and cannot give the quiet space any rasa name categorically for I don’t know what is lying further underneath in deeper layers of the mind and being.  Nevertheless, for this layer, there was a quiet breathing that I was connected with, and there is a Friend that I seem to be continuously in touch with. Feelings of clarity, fear, tentativeness, a definitive conviction and awareness of what I am doing at the moment, were all seemingly being held simultaneously.

A nuance of holding space that I got in touch with in the sessions mentioned above: during the pair dancing (with palms or fingers touching and no talking), the experience that when I actually stopped trying to lead and fighting the resistance (even when it was my turn to lead), and simply left my palm there, it became the other’s responsibility and effort to hold on and follow. My palm was simply there and the process started shifting from leading-following to simply a natural dance and co-holding of space.  I was holding this awareness within me as I went into the event.  Thank you Ganesh for demonstrating this beautifully during ECC programme.

I am also aware that the action and conviction, the sense of quietness will not stay just this way all the time. This sort of a being is also due to the external influences and satsangam of, KMS at Hyderabad, Parenting Retreat, ECC, circles and conversations here in Tiruvannamalai, and individual interactions with several of you**.  So much is happening on the outside to keep this going.  And a couple of other things that I have been doing / practicing (including asana-py-bhavana- of course), which have started the important work of establishing some of these new movements within me firmly.  There are and will be times when all the external support systems are not there and I am by myself, and those will be the test of how much I have been able to stabilise this ground and will tell me where I need to intensify efforts, what I am missing from the whole picture and so on.  What I hold here is also the dance between community / support systems and standing alone, which seems to be especially important for us as practitioners, (training to) hold space for others to explore / discover / understand in different formats.  

I got in touch with what feels to me as a significant factor in the ways I have been listening and what I need to pay close attention to.  I am realising that I saw it perhaps because of that space of quietness and awareness that I carried with me into the event. This was allowing all my senses to be so wide awake and I was both listening to the outside and inside at the same time.  Ok, cut the hemming and hawing already.  It has been and probably still is difficult for me to stay with and even look at my vulnerabilities, leave alone sharing them, putting them out on the table, unless the other is expansive and strong enough to hold space for me to do this in a safe and comfortable way. However I am inclined to intense feelings, passions and able to inspire and evoke others to touch their passions, deepest desires as I have often experienced.  What has been happening in the interface is that, I evoke this in the other just as I do for myself, but then run away or get into escape routes just as the going gets intense, and I leave the other perhaps hanging or colluding.  The intensity of the evocations touches my most vulnerable spot every time – the tension between who I am and who I am not.  I am always guarding who I am, and afraid that who-I-am-not will change or invade who-I-am.  This is also why when the other provides a ‘safe’ environment, (which for me is, not threatening my sense of who I am), I can let go and be ‘myself’ and end up indulging the ‘who-I-am’ and not stepping back and examining this process.  I had been unable to stay with this tension between the I-am and I-am-not, and so whenever the exchange starts getting into this tension area, it gets intense (if it already was not!) , I would quickly jump into my fortress and deploying, possibly, all kinds of weapons from there, just varying degrees of potency.  And I can get intense about the batting of an eyelid! 

The sad part of this process is that because of years of practice of building up the fortress, it has become a habit.  So even in moments when there is actually no real fear, simply the force of habit takes over.  I am feeling immensely sad because of all the pictures that are coming up for me just now when I have allowed a particular moment to wilt or not bloom to its full beauty and authentic expression because of the guard.  I am realising that the sadness is from a mixture of love (of the other and people and discoveries and unfolding) and anger (at myself that I have not given this space for myself and my world).

I am seeing the friend sitting here with me, just now after some breath-watching and shifting focus to some immediate domestic chores for a few minutes. She is holding a lot of kindness for me and is reminding me of the magic of this entire process and to keep at it.  I remember this sutra that Raghu brought up during ECC, which took off like a flashbulb inside me: Smrti-parishuddhau svarūpa-shunya iva artha-mātra-nirbhāsā nir-vitarkā (YS 1.43).  I experienced tangibly with the veeryam (mentioned in the 2nd para), how just the act of giving attention to something can momentarily shift the entire picture.  And then it’s ‘just’ continuing to give attention!  J

Today is the first day of the Tamil month of Thai.  A proverb goes, “தை பிறந்தால் வழி பிறக்கும்” (rough translation of the essence in this context: with the month of Thai comes a new beginning).  A tangible bhavana / exercise / activity that I need to do as preparation before every event is: walking out of the fortress and into the gardens, fields and forests out there, and meet and walk with friends under the open sky.  The giripradakshina around Arunachala comes up for me as a space and time when I feel open, vulnerable and strong.  

--------------------------------------------------------
** - friends (co-practitioners and colleagues)

Saturday, December 2, 2017

Where from my Muse?


This essay is inspired by a friend's question on reading one of my poems. Here is the complete poem. 

One of the stanzas has the lines, 

"She sees these portals of Purity 
Her mind's eyes turning Red,
As she contemplates her anger and disgust.
 "  

And follows up the above lines with, 

"With a sigh of quiet resolve,
She turns to the day ahead,
..."   

The friend's question is, 'How did the anger and disgust transform?'  (I am guessing, such that there could be a "quiet resolve" in the next line). My initial reaction was along the lines, "this is the practitioner's work, our entire practice is that transformation(?); it is each one's journey and the 'how' of this transformation (if at all) is a wheel that has to be turned time and again, it is different for different entities..." 

However, from awareness of some movements that happened in the mind exactly at that inflexion point, and for the joy of this examination, I write further. 

An opening to the examination could be, I dont really think that the anger and disgust transformed into something else. 

The original last line of that stanza that had floated in my mind was "As she contemplates flying away".  I paused at that point, looked up at my beloved, sacred hill, drew him in with my breath, held him, allowed him to pervade my being, and that union flowed out through my pen with my exhalation. I changed the words to the current ones as my contemplation did, and sat watching this and my breath for a short while (or it could have been an eternity) before the next line happened. 

I could dedicate this process to my daily, long-standing practice of asana-pranayama-meditative-enquiry, that seems to have a life of its own, and takes matters into its own hands sometimes. The yoga sutra, "Sa tu dheergakala nairantarya satkara adhara asevito drdha bhoomih" (I.14) comes to mind. [Meaning of sutra: Practice becomes firmly established when it is cultivated uninterruptedly and with devotion over a prolonged period of time]. 

And I could dedicate this timely intervention to the grace of Arunachala whose town I reside in. “Bhagavat Kaingaryam” (roughly, the grace of the Universe / God / Higher forces) according to elders.

Much of the time all that seems to be needed is that pause and space for observation; space for just being with what arises, between one line and the next, one step and the next, one kshanam (approximately, a moment) and the next.

Examining further, that space of contemplation and what was happening for me then; I feel that words may never be able to capture those sensations and nuances of movement precisely. I can at best say that, a larger love, understanding, happened in those moments. Many pictures and scenes from my life, and of others flashed in front of my eyes like a movie, and some questions arose. Amidst pictures of many blurred uncertainties, the next certain lines presented themselves to my mind’s eye in sharp focus, even as I continued to watch my breath.

I did not see anger and disgust transforming into anything else. In retrospect, I think that the pictures I saw were of instances where these emotions were held and expressed in different ways (I want to add the word ‘appropriately’ here, but tentatively and with a question mark for I can only speculate on the appropriateness or lack thereof).

And with quiet resolve, the crow could have flown way to other parts to scavenge. She could have transformed to other colours, birds, doing other things, each of them possibly pausing on other terraces and window-sills and returning to crowhood. To burst again into more colours. I don’t know for sure, the possibilities are endless. It may be another story the next day. A different crow perhaps.  

Herein for me lies the Art of it all. The art of writing. The art of this very life. Many have looked at the meaning of art in their lives and tried to describe it. For me, all Art seems to be a search and / or expression of glimpses of an Infinite source of everything. It seems like we are trying to touch and express something that is eternal, infinite through what we can hold of transient and finite life, and death.

A painter is trying to capture the eternal beauty underneath the grotesque ugliness of urban landscapes that he is seeing. A husband illustrates the small moments of togetherness with his wife and family, attempting to put in his frames, everlasting love. Look at the temple of Arunachaleshwara here in Tiruvannamalai. There is something larger than life, larger than the finite hands and bodies of the sculptors and workers that flow through the stone. What infinity did they see that transformed their finiteness?

I am seeing Art as the channel, the medium of that infinite source within us, within everywhere. And by this very nature, art lends itself to other factors:

-       It is a process that is ongoing and reflective. I believe that it is not possible to touch, glimpse or taste something in the subtler and finer realms, and give over to meta processes, with the cognitive mind.  By the very swadharma of being art, it forgets / bypasses the cognitive mind and reaches beyond this to a space of insights and subtle sensing. And this space is that of Nature, of Life, of Reality – which means it is ever-changing, it is a process. It cannot be bottled or packaged into a static form of time and space. How paradoxical it is that we need to dive into a space of ever-changing change in a search for the constant!  A corollary is that it is possible to express from that reflective state. Art is that expression. It is also true that in expression, the cognitive mind can also jump in out of sheer habit and propensity. It may also happen that a cognitive mind and expression is necessary.  And this brings us to another factor:   

-       That of context. Very often (I actually want to say, ‘at all times’) the manifestations depend on the context. There are many who would refute this factor. In any case, we cannot really have conclusions. I believe that we are not looking only at art and the artist. Both, the artist and the process of art exist in a context, and this context I believe is alive in them, whether the artist is conscious of it or not, whether others in the context are conscious of it or not. This is most visible in performance art, in theatre.  The art is not simply a rehearsed piece that is performed on stage. Art is happening with the active participation of the audience during the performance. It is an alive conversation.  The conversations get more complex when the art involves, say, a poem. Like mine for instance. The artist dwells on her reflections, and in the process of creation / art. There are times when a third (say, you, the reader) is already present even during the creation (like with this essay) and there are other times when there may not be a conscious intention of presentation (like with the poem). Even here there are complexities that can be examined, and conversations with the self, abound. When a reader actively enters the scene, he / she brings in her reflections and is creating art anew then. There are questions of belonging and ownership that come up for me here. The same piece of expression could become an object of analysis and cognition the next day.

Like today, I am looking at ‘my’ crow fairly analytically and dissecting it, while also attempting to reflect and put together a larger picture. And we could still be in the realm of Art. Or not.

For my crow this moment
is empty
and still,
all the anger
and disgust
having become
foam and froth
with the water in spate,
that flooded
every nook and corner,
purifying,
taking with it
fishes and plastic
garbage
and plant matter
all the same,
while gushing downstream,
towards its destiny.

--------------------------------------------

Notes :-
-       At this point, the YS II.48 comes to mind – “Tato dvandvanabhighatah” – From this, one is not afflicted by the dualities of the opposites.

-       I must say thanks to my friend and co-sadhaka who spotted the exact point of inflexion and asked the question which wouldn’t leave until I wrote this.

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

A Soliloquy on Identity – Part III: This Moment is its Own Affirmation


Or I could borrow Joseph Campbell’s quote, “You become mature when you become the authority of your own life” for the title of this essay in the Identity series.

I could title it, “Who Am I?” or “The Pathless Path”, if I wanted this chapter to be the beginning of the next section of my autobiography!   

The earlier essay, I left off with saying that needing recognition seems to be one of my fundamental patterns.  In fact, this had been occupying such density in my being that it has taken all this time to stay and work with this part of me and arrive at a location to pen it down. 

We all need affirmation one way or another from our people, our audiences, clients, friends, children, parents… I am seeing around me that most of us need affirmation of various kinds.  This plays out in our lives at different levels and intensities, and we make up some of our narratives depending on our experiences with affirmation (or lack of it), how we understand and learn to handle / mishandle / be with, this need.  And so, what if the normal need for affirmation that begins in a child and can regulate itself into a healthy feedback mechanism for coherent functioning as the child grows older, becomes a hidden (even to herself), compulsive seeking of affirmation through various means and ways even as an adult?

The recognition that I wanted / needed from my world is nothing but simple (or not so simple!) affirmation that I did not get as a child.  I had been an adult by age, living and functioning as an adult outside, driven by the child’s need for affirmation, inside. Carl Jung had said, “Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate”.   This is true for me, except that I don’t call it ‘fate’.  This unconscious relationship with affirmation that I have had made my choices, determined much of my action and has also limited who I am up until now. 

The relationship – I sought affirmation from the authority figures in my life (either I set them up so and they colluded, or vice versa).  And my story has been that I don’t get the affirmation that I want / need from them (since I didn’t get it as a child).  Hence I also set up the stage for not receiving the affirmation from these authority figures. Then I don’t conform, I rebel ‘against’ these authority figures and take up causes to do so.  I became the rebel against any system (for me, authority), the angry young man syndrome.  I constructed my identity, my idea of self, out of this relationship with authority and affirmation.  One of my primary narratives had been this: whoever I see as authority will ‘fail’ me by not affirming me in the ways that I need, and I will find some way to be the righteous rebel, try to get out of the web of authority and strike my own path.  There will be a flash of brilliance as I try to find myself, but I will set myself up to fail, because the sense of self was so enmeshed with the idea of being affirmed by authority, that if there was no authority, there was no self.  Who will affirm me? I was trapped in my cyclical story for the longest while.

However, there is more than one story in the unconscious that direct one’s life. In fact, there are several, and we collect more on the way.  I call in Thoreau along with Jung into this essay, “We are constantly invited to be who we are”.   And so, even though I chose the affirmation one as my primary story, there were others whispering and flirting and gesturing and waving for my elusive attention.  I noticed one such when it simply wouldn’t be ignored – my story of practice versus / and theory, also a gift from my family.  My well, rendered dry with intellect alone, was searching for the water of practice. This took me to the practice of asana-pranayama, and the path of yoga.  This ongoing story led me then to many others, and some more, and continues.  They started knocking on my door time and again as seemingly far-fetched opportunities, uncomfortable questions, bursts of colour, myriad meanings and metaphors, insights …
  
The righteousness soon dropped away.  The rebel is a warrior and this part of cell memory doesn’t get erased that easily I find.  However, she has learnt to set down her arms and keep her sword sheathed unless she feels it necessary to fight.  She has also learnt to see that there are ways and ways of putting up a fight.  There is another story in this of course, that of finding the woman, the shakti.  There is no cause or context for rebellion in these tales.  There is also a story of what to fight for, which is a wondrous one, that of Mother Earth, as ancient as she.  

When these masks were removed, I had to face my vulnerabilities: there is no authority to get affirmation from.  There need be none.  I am not that child who did not get the affirmations she needed, any longer.  I am an adult with many gifts, many stories, having a child of my own whom I need to affirm in many ways while giving her space to grow independent.  But where and how is my affirmation happening? How can I design a wholesome feedback process for myself? Do I need such a thing or is it my need for affirmation acting up? What would I be without this need and seeking for affirmation from authority? What would I be owning up to authority where it is required? Is authority even required or is my mind playing games? What am I missing?  

I turned to my asana-pranayama-swadhyayam, practice, as usual, and a question that stayed is, ‘what would I be without this need, free from this cycle?’  The practitioner and teacher in me joyfully announced the experience: that the practice itself is the affirmation – this moment is its own affirmation.  I realised the truth of this somewhat. When I am practicing, and when I am teaching someone for therapeutic purposes, I need no validation for what I am doing.  I am deeply into the process, and it runs the show.  Every step and moment speaks for itself and illumines the next.  My authority comes from my personal practice and the needs of the process when necessary. 

But, what does this mean for my question?  Who am I by myself? What is my process then if that is what I am looking for?  The stories that came knocking now were vague sightings into a dark wilderness that I began to see from the edges but didn’t initially venture into, being fearful of what I may find.  Tentative steps and short trips into the forest revealed more stories. Walking alone in the moonlight breathes energy into this quest.  Walking alone, even more.  Stories of art, aesthetics, writing and beauty rose up from the unconscious.  An avalanche of memory, I remember the numerous instances that I had bypassed when life had been inviting me to be who I am.  How did I not attend these stories earlier?!  

But there is no path prescribed by any authority in that wilderness.  I need to plunge headlong into it. I smell a story of fear here.  Fear holds me back from making that dive.  Fear of what? Perhaps of making mistakes.  What is the question I need to ask now? It strikes me that I am not afraid of making mistakes in my personal practice, or even with a student.  I completely trust the process and the relationship and there is an element of something much larger than merely ‘I’ that I give up myself to.  I believe that this something may be the grace of the universe, god… that is always available to each of us. The “Ishvarapranidhana” that Yoga sutras mention. How do I open myself to receive it? How is it that I can feel this in asana-pranayama and not with this fear that holds me a prisoner? Or am I just trying to escape into a variable called Ishvara and say, this is all I can do, that this is my best? What is the fear holding me?  The fear that I may be wrong about all of this: perhaps I am imagining the stories of creating and writing and art, perhaps I am not this at all. But why does fear stop my action? Can I move despite fear? I see a story of the habit of fear. How do I engage with this? 

I remember the first time I went into Sirsasana (headstand). It was a surprise. Had I known earlier that our goal posture for that day’s group practice was headstand, I would have skipped the class. Just 3-4 postures before our goal, it was mentioned casually that we need to prepare in that current posture well, if we wanted to go up on our heads.  My hands went cold and clammy, thinking of my positional vertigo condition etc. But the environment of my yoga sangha, colleagues and friends doing the practice, the instructor (whose sirsasana is to die for!), and my commitment to improvement in asana-PY practice made me stay.  I still can taste the ramyam of going up on my head that day. 

Perhaps I need to surprise myself out of my fear of being wrong.  How? And even if I am wrong, what other choice do I have?  All I have are these stories and my practice. I have nowhere to escape, no masks to hide behind, and I don't want them.  I am in this space from which there is no going back and the way forward and sideways is a jungle with no path.  Just many symbols and metaphors and ideas and a quest for beauty.

I cannot see the path ahead all that clearly, and I do not know for sure that this is a pattern that has stopped “directing my life” as Jung says. But I can say definitively that my mind cannot even turn in the direction of my affirmation-need without me being aware of it, and pausing to look at it with careful caution and interest, and also keep the wilderness in view.  Perhaps my short forays in, will prepare me to walk straight and deep into the jungle one of these days without returning to safety. 


Saturday, March 26, 2016

A Soliloquy on Identity - Part II (Viśokā vā jyotiṣmatị̄**)

In part I of this soliloquy, I had talked about seeing reality as is, and about a sense of lightness when I drop all my luggage in perception (my filters), and seeing as is. I had had this feeling of lightness, of not being weighted down when some of the filters dropped.  I had also mentioned in consequence, finding the inner light that ends sorrow, Viśokā vā jyotiṣmatị̄**.  


While examining the identity statement that I had mentioned in Part I, “I am a Yoga teacher, therefore I am”, some scenarios came up when I was almost violating another’s space by imposing my yoga solutions onto the situation.  I looked at one of them from various angles.  For example, I asked myself, “what if I did not play the role of a yoga teacher in that space / situation”. Instead, I played only the primary role - that of a friend in said situation. What would I have said and done and not said and not done? How would it have played out? Some clear visuals emerged wherein I was demonstrating being that yoga teacher, true to the qualities of one as I see it and as I have studied, and true to being a friend, listening completely, than when I had carried the tag of ‘yoga teacher’ in me. When that tag (extra baggage) dropped, I felt free, content, unburdened, and there was a burst of light in the region of my heart. This was momentary, and brought to mind, Patanjali’s sutra, Viśokā vā jyotiṣmatị̄** (YS 1.36). In retrospect, it was an apt sutra that presented itself to my mind - because, as it happened for me, when inner disturbance (caused by my stuckness to an identity) subsided, even for a moment, the pain of it also did ( I felt free of it,viśokā), thus discovering inner luminosity (jyotiṣmatị̄) - my burst of light.


However, beyond the momentary feeling, all this is pure speculation on my part to try and fit the sutra to that experience because they happened contiguously. I also see that I am “attached” to my insights and experiences in swadhyaya, such that I cannot edit them out in even in presentation. And this word, attachment, is important, as my examination seemed to point out to me, which I will come to by and by.


The fleeting high faded and the tension of the examination returned in the next few moments with a question that my mind threw up, “but I am a yoga teacher, how can I not own up to it, there must be ways where I can keep my commitment to being a yoga teacher and still not violate another”.  Alright then.  I took a deep breath and parked the question for the next day’s āsana-pranayama time, allowing it to simmer in the back chambers until then.


So, I decided to dig into the dense phrase, “I am a yoga teacher” - what in the beingness of the yoga teacher do I identify with?


  1. My personal practice of āsana and prāṇāyāma is a non-negotiable part of me being a yoga teacher, because it is the practice that reveals to me what I can teach. However, does this mean that I will not practice if I am not teaching actively? No. My time on the mat is also in some ways the bedrock of my swadhyaya.  I understand my own intentions, emotions and directions deeply, and any ability to stay anchored and dance with all of this comes through my practice. So while the identity of yoga teacher includes in itself the component of āsana-prāṇāyāma and meditative practices, these are today a part of my functioning as a coherent human being.  So in fact, this is a part of my identity as a human being and I can probably ‘lose’ my practice only if I lose my memory, in which case I would not remember any methods and techniques to innovate and create new spaces and ways of sustaining practice and so on.  The process of slowly eliminating component after component of my yoga practice and seeing what remains, that I had written about more in Part I, has been viscerally important, because it confronted head-on some key fears that I held (hold?), and lent itself to discovering the creative ways of working with and sustaining my practice that I had just mentioned above. And hence, I also challenged the attachment that I felt to different parts and aspects of my practice, and the benefits that I think I am getting thereof.  This is when some part of the denseness of the identity started clearing up. Could I go through my practice and its experience, being committed to it, and yet not get attached / stuck to any of it such that I can move on when the next moment presents a new situation to me?  An example that presented itself to me: we all say “get on the mat” for doing the practice, and I use this term quite seriously and extensively - I realised that the āsana component of the practice was (is?) something in the zone of attachment for me. The few days that only prāṇāyāma is possible, surface level acceptance would actually be hiding dissatisfaction. Fine then, what if I cannot “get on the mat”, for practice? What if I could only sit on a chair and breathe? What if my practice could consist only of prāṇāyāma?


This process has moved me definitively in the direction of carrying my practice lighter, and much more in the realm of, it being a commitment and responsibility, which I believe is vital in the smaller and larger social contexts that I live in.  The idea of carrying my practice lighter is something I will examine later.


The discussion is about what in the beingness about a yoga teacher do I identify with.  To continue,


  1. It seems very important to me that I help others with their healing and learning processes (and particularly in and through the framework of yoga).  I find such empowerment, continue to heal and understand phenomena in finer ways, in and through my yoga practices, that it becomes crucial for me to facilitate this for others. Why does the latter feel consequential to the former? I have an idea and will get into it through the conversation.  I work with therapy - using āsana and prāṇāyāma courses and techniques therapeutically, say, to alleviate pain, to work with stress, handling disease and disorder and so on.  Āsana and prāṇāyāma practice is like a magic potion that works in miraculous ways to heal the body.  Where nothing else moved my chronic wheezing disorder a millimetre, my yoga practice did.  And how! The key inspiring factor for me in this process is that the raw material and the medicine is (in) one’s self - body, mind and breath.  One needs nothing extraneous1.  This for me lends passion; it is deeply satisfying for me when another feels this sense of empowerment, say for instance, by arriving at an underlying cause for pain in his / her body.


In one way, this empowering that another feels justifies for me my personal practice.  My body and mind is the laboratory.  Teaching another means responsibility, and thus also accountability.  I cannot instruct students without having practiced myself - by this I mean the process of practice, of putting myself through the methods and applications that I may put my students through.  And so we come to the matter of teaching being consequential to personal practice.  I don't exist in a time-space warp of my own - I am made alive and express myself in the contexts and relationships that I live and move in.  And to this extent I am completely connected with everything and everyone around me.  We all experience and manifest these connections in small and big, myriad ways.  I see again and again that my relationship with myself manifests in my relationships with the other.


I believe that it is also a cultural learning and value that I carry - that there is a single thread running through all of creation and all divisions are perceptions.  Hence it is also a logical conclusion that whatever I do to/with the ‘other’ I am doing to/with myself and vice versa. We have grown up listening to stories like that of Ramanuja who was told that sharing the mantra that he had learnt with others would mean that the benefits of the mantra wouldn’t accrue to him, and yet, he went ahead and shouted out his teachings from the top of the temple to all who would listen; listening to the value in many stories like this that puts the other first, in our relationships and in different contexts. I realise that this is a background chant that goes on in my culture.


Like many others that I know, I had made this into an oppressive “should” (‘should put the other before myself’) for the very longest time, judged myself negatively and finding myself limited and yet being pulled and acting on strong desires that seem to put me before others, seeing ‘negative’ outcomes, slapping more judgments on myself, and tightening the ‘should’ noose further. This had become a self-fulfilling, degenerative loop. The obvious but regularly missed twist in the story is that what I do to myself, I do to the other.  As a result, many of what had been judgments on myself, got translated and projected as expectations on and from the other. For instance, I judged, losing my cool in a bus and ranting at someone for not passing my money to the conductor, as totally uncouth and uncalled for. (alright, I called myself worse names!) I am not sure if it is obvious, that then I would / may expect my neighbour in a bus not to yell at me if I were unwilling to pass her / his money because of a genuine circumstance.  And expectations blind us from perceiving and understanding the other’s reality and situation. To cut a longer story short, my yoga process cut into the degenerative pattern and stayed with it, and at some point glimpses of the true value of the cultural learning of oneness started showing up, and continue to do so, in countless connections and interrelationship. What remains mostly is the teaching being a consequence and natural extension of practice - a strong thread holding this identity together.


Then, what if I were not able to teach due to life circumstances? I went through the questioning, eliminating and reflective writing2,3.  This has been a tough premise and process, even painful. My mind either refused to stay with it or offered collusions which I accepted until further reflection established them to be what they are really. By collusion here I mean easy scenarios, conclusions and explanations that the mind presents us with regularly to either hide behind or to cover the truth of the situation.  This is the mind’s way of coping and not looking at hard realities which it is unable to accept.  


What remains is the question for me to stay with.  I realise that I cannot in truth ‘resolve’ it.  This can happen (if at all) only if the situation comes to pass (my mind is automatically saying “God forbid!”), that is, with the experience of it. Until then, any ‘resolution’ will remain intellectual.  Life is happening in the meanwhile and I can be alive, vibrant by staying with the question and hence with the possibilities that get thrown up in my relationship with my question.  I am probably going to dig into this further, later.


For now, to move on with the present discussion of what in the beingness of the yoga teacher do I identify with,


  1. It also seems that I seek to be seen and known as a yoga teacher.  This recognition is important for me.  In fact, this conversation on identity began faintly in my mind with a discussion about ‘recognition’ several years ago, with an artist friend.  He was telling me that it doesn't matter to him if he does not get the credits for his work (art).  My point had been that this could be indifference to one’s work / commitment at some level, wearing the mask of virtue.  Today, I think that it could additionally be masking fear of failure or non-acceptance (not necessarily in the case of my friend).  Actually, he was so much at peace (or seemed to be so) with what he was saying, and I felt I knew him enough to think that he is not an ‘indifferent’ person. However, this conversation lodged in my mind to come up time and again, because I realised even then that I seemed to need recognition for my work, for all that I am and do.  
Now, examination reveals that I don’t seem to seek recognition from strangers. It may be fine with me, say, to have my work in the public domain with no one unknown to me, knowing its my work.  I seem to seek recognition from my own world, the people I know, love, respect and admire. I will go down this road a little later.


Right now, I sit down to look at something that has come up a couple of times in the examination, and came up again at present with this question: will I continue to work even if I do not get this recognition from my people?  Yes, I most certainly will, however, the way I work, what I feel while working, my expectations, how much of myself I invest, all of this will depend on the extent of my attachment to the recognition and to the seeking of it.  Here is ‘attachment’ again.  The intensity of attachment I feel to the various aspects of the identity statement seems to be determining their respective forms.  On the surface it may seem obvious: “Hey, you are talking about what you identify yourself with - you are then attached to it, right?” Right. So, let’s dig into that attachment.  Perhaps the matter of attachment is one of degree. Intensity.  When I am stuck in these identities, then I cannot flow with the current.  Then that creates disturbance, suffering. The more intense my attachment to (my idea of) recognition, the more intense is my suffering!


Here is my feeling of viśokā, my jyotiṣmatị̄ again**.  And here is yet, my attachment to the sutra! It’s time to stay and simmer with the question of attachment, and that of attachment to recognition.

---------------
** Viśokā vā jyotiṣmatị̄ - The classical commentary and interpretation of this sutra is "finding the inner light that ends sorrow". As explained by one of my teachers, this is based on a "particular practice of seeing the light travel through the Nadis, emanating from the Daharam, the minute space where the prānā, jeevātma and paramātma reside". It becomes necessary to state this since I have incorporated the sutra into my own experience and interpreted the sequence of the phenomenon to suit me.

1 One of course needs a teacher and may need crutches and aids sometimes to achieve certain functions, but the reader is requested to see the essence of what is being said - that the body-mind-breath is the medicine, besides also, self-effort or Will if you want, which is the raw material (the potential), and hence one already has what it takes.   


2 In fact, this series of longform essays is based on the notes from my reflective writing besides the examination and drawing, and then fleshed out with some thinking, studying, and editing and further writing.


3 Reflective writing is meta work. Meaning, it is writing based on what is happening with the writer and the writing while writing; her emotions primarily and secondary processes based on those. It is not writing based on thought, analysis and intellectual processes. However, by the very nature of the writing, this aspect (of form, and process in this case) also comes under the microscope of the process since the dominant and pervasive mental activity of these times seems to be intellectual thought, and it is quite easy for this part of the mind to take over and masquerade.  

Sunday, February 14, 2016

A Soliloquy on Identity - Part I (Looking through the lens of the Yoga Sutra)

So many of our routine, everyday statements are identity statements - what I am, what I am not, What I like, What I dont like, What so-and-so does to me, I dont usually....

And I carry all my identities with me, all the time, protect and nourish them, put them in glossy packages, unpack and repack and organise them in various ways.

All these identities create the form of the 'I' - Asmita1 (YS2 II.3, II.6).  This means that the more identities I collect, and create distinct shapes of the 'I', the more distinct, clear form of the 'I' emerges, and gets sharper and sharper.  And I get stuck in that asmita. 

"I am a Yoga teacher, therefore I am" 

Now, wow. That is a strong identity that I seem to be carrying.  Even as I am writing it, I can feel its pull-push. I am quick to put up defences to protect this statement (identity) and my mind seems to be bent on sabotaging any efforts on my part to try and play with this statement, try and drop it and see.  It took a long while for me to stay with trying to drop this. So my hands and feet became cold, my stomach started churning.  I stayed with these sensations and persisted with trying to drop it, by returning to it after every distraction and detour that my mind presented to me.    
What if my limbs do not move, are paralysed? I cant do the āsana practice that am able to do today. I have my breath, my head and neck can still move, perhaps my hip can twist. Alright. 
What if I lost my voice? Maybe I cant facilitate and instruct to teach others.  Perhaps I will come up with other ways to teach. 
I went on in this manner, until I reached bare basics - being left with my breath and mantra for a personal practice. 
Then, what if I started losing my memory...

So, reality is changing all the time. Sat Vada and Parinama Vada - What I am experiencing now is true, and that it is changing is also true. However, I find that my identities are not fluid enough to change and move with reality.  I am stuck in the clear shape of the "I" that I have created.  I only see my identity, not reality. 

How do I see reality, as is? What has helped me is my āsana and prāṇāyāma practice, and swadhyaya.  Though consisting of many methods and exercises to help facilitate self reflection, my swadhyaya has been to a large extent through my āsana-prāṇāyāma practice, locating myself in my body and understanding how it works, and through this, my mind.  This has helped me to at least step in the right direction many times, sometimes to have glimpses of situations, myself, the world around me, without the filter of my identities.  By "step in the right direction" I mean, to begin to notice an identity statement, understand its triggers, origin, how it works (in) me; such that at some point I can begin to work it, play with it and so on.  Something like what I did earlier with the yoga teacher identification. 

When I see reality, as is, there is no identification, no identity, only reality.  I drop all the luggage I am carrying and hence there is a sense of lightness.  Then one may find the inner light that ends sorrow, "Viśokā vā jyotiṣmatị̄" (YS, I. 36).  

But then, I do need identity.  I am reminded of the story of the mendicant and his loin cloth that was told by one of my teachers recently.  That mendicant identified with 'his' piece of loin cloth so much that he slowly started accumulating other identities one after another, in protecting that one, until he had a homestead, complete with wife, children, cows, the works.  His single piece of cloth became his consuming identity. He made it so.  However, what about the will to practice every day?  I need my will to do my sadhana in the direction of "Chitta Vritti Nirodha" (YS, I. 2), when all the movements of the mind cease. That will is part of Asmita, and it is necessary for me, to get to the point where it drops away by itself.  

Until then, I do need the Asmita. Actually, whether I need it or not is immaterial. It remains! All I can do is to acknowledge it, examine it, inquire and stay with my practice.  However, as a Yoga practitioner, I am given a direction, and clear signposts on the path to see if my asmita is moving in the right direction - the Yamas (signposts of ethical conduct) and Niyamas, observances towards self discipline (YS, II.28 to II.32).  

The niyamas, inner and outer purity (Sauca), contentment (Santosha), austerity (Tapas), self reflection / study (Swadhyaya) and surrendering to a higher intelligence (Ishwarapranidhana) are clear ways of quietening the mind / checking in with one's quietening, such that the self more and more stays with itself - self discipline. Prana gets dissipated lesser and lesser as the niyamas strengthen. This gets manifested externally as the yamas - not-violating (Ahimsa), seeking truth (Satya), not wanting that which is not one's (Asteya), moving towards truth / continence (Brahmacarya) and not being covetous (Aparigraha).  Patanjali goes on further to state that staying with the yamas unconditionally, irrespective of circumstances, is a great vow. And I am discovering in my practice that staying with the niyamas facilitate the yamas.  These two for me are intertwined, braided together with the same thread, lending themselves to my favourite definition of Yoga, as relationship, as union (although in seeming contradiction, it is also about separation of the "I" from Identity!). What I do with the other, I do with myself. What I do with myself, I do with the other.  This is a simple truth that has been coming up again and again in my practice.  How much of my fears I project to the people closest to me. How I have been taking on my parents' anger. How much of love reflects and re-reflects like in a hall of mirrors with my children. The niyamas work with the "I" and the "I"; the yamas with the "I" and the "other".  Each reflect the other.  How beauty. 

In considering the beauty of this connection, I feel that all the components of the yoga practice are so woven together, intricately.  I find such logic in the connections that make that fabric.  It is commonly felt and said that āsana practice today has been taken out of the larger context of yoga sadhana itself and practising postures for physical fitness and beauty alone will take us away from wholesome meaning and direction.  However, then that cannot be Yoga. The practice leads us to the next step.  I have found in my āsana practice, that whenever I allow the intelligence of my body to lead the way, I make progress with the practice in whatever way. "In whatever way" is important because many times our minds set goals or targets for the practice that are not in tune with the inherent rhythm and intelligence.  Remember, its a mind that is stuck in its identities.  Hence, the surrendering to the inherent intelligence is a useful check-in. So, whenever I am struggling in the practice, it is more often than not that I have stopped listening to that inherent intelligence, wisdom, and have allowed the mind to take over.  Then I've got to simply exhale, and inhale and allow the practice to fill me.  It will show me the next step.  Vyaasa states in his commentary to YS III.63, "Yogena Yogo Jnaatavyo; Yogo yogaatpravartate" (Yoga is known by yoga; Yoga becomes manifest by yoga").   And hence, even if practiced for supposedly lesser goals (check-in: this could be an identity statement if we are making it so), the āsana practice could inevitably lead the practitioner to the other components in the path (they are so connected) and thus facilitate meaning and direction. 

But yes, what is required is to get on that mat, every single day. I cant lose my practice. It took me 6 years of irregular, irreverent and piecemeal practice and corresponding benefits before I committed to deep and steadfast practice.  It took another 4 years of that practice, before I was ready for the practice to show me the next leg of the journey. If my practice is consistent, and I keep returning to it without losing my way and I do so again and again because I hold my practice in such faith, reverence, then yes, it holds steady and stable and shows me the next ground to achieve, "Sa tu dheergakala nairantarya satkara adhara asevito drdha bhoomih" (YS I.14). It is just right here to pause and feel the gratitude for a teacher who had immense faith in me and never let up on me, never gave up on me. It took a while before it sunk in that it is simply her process, her faith in her practice that propelled and reflected her. How best can I honour this tradition of teaching and learning than to offer her and all my teachers and this tradition (where the greatest teachers have teachers), all my practice and continue the work.  

So the more work I do, intense āsana-prāṇāyāma practice, and understand through āsana more and more of how my body works, and through that, my breath and my mind, initially going in and out of swadhyaya and then at some point, firmly being established in the ground and practice of swadhyaya, more are the insights that I seem to gather about the workings of the "I" and the world and the engagement of the "I" with the world.  And then, I start identifying with my insights.  After all, I do have the working of the asmita within me. My insights start becoming more identity statements that I gather and may hoard.  I have newer insights and carry those luggages too.  I can forget on a daily basis that the measure of what is real is changing from moment to moment - Maya. And get stuck to the insights of the previous moment and start thinking that I am the next best thing to Patanjali! Bhrantidarshana - misapprehension / delusion.  This one obstacle that Patanjali mentions in the path of practice, is a quagmire and can in a snowballing effect lead to all the other obstacles that are mentioned. (YS I.30, vyadhi styana samshaya pramada alasya aviratti bhrantidarshana alabdabhoomikatva anavastitattvani chitta vikshepa te antarayah) In my experience, any one or the other can lead to the rest in a chain reaction. I am ill and weak, more liable to fears and doubts, my mind could be hazy and unclear leading to fatigue and carelessness, which leads to mistakes, then I doubt my abilities and my path, want to try other things and regress in the progress I have made so far.  This is the simplest and most obvious connecting chain of reaction that I see time and again.  Another cycle could begin with self-doubt, a complete non-starter freezing action, evoking inertia, and over time carelessness, leading to misapprehension and restlessness, giving way to taking refuges in different ways, further leading to ill health, inconsistency and regression in practice. 

I am in the trap of bhrantidarshana.  What now? Here is where the yamas and niyamas come into play. The logic of the yamas and niyamas is inescapable.  I simply get on the mat again the next day. I do my prāṇāyāma. I have my breath. I inhale my commitment to practice and inquiry.  I exhale and seek the truth.  I hold ahimsa as the paramo dharma and in reverence my dialogue with compassion in intent, word, action and response, and above all, offer every moment of practice in surrender to this Universe. (YS 1.34, Pracchardana vidaranabhyamva praanasya) I live the prasada that the Universe gives me. And the cycle starts again the next inhale / exhale. As I allow this prana that is born every moment to suffuse my body, my being, it leads me to "what now". I am then in that apavarga location (of learning and inquiry) and all that I see is for me to learn, understand and move towards truth and freedom, and I do not consume and / or be consumed by the experience (say, of Bhrantidarshana)  (YS II.18, Prakasha kriya sthiti sheelam bhootendriyatmakam bhogaapavargartham drshyam).  I stay and watch the bhrantidarshana, watch the mind perform its tricks and understand some more. 

What I see is that, even as I read and talk about dropping the mind and getting into the realm of being a witness, an observer (the drshta), it is all still the mind. It is the mind which is observing itself. And hence there is a chance it gets sharper and clearer with relentless practice. There is also the chance here again of bhrantidarshana, I can easily think that I am already so much in the observer state, that I am the observer (though the thinking faculty is still the mind!).  This could be the ultimate bhrantidarshana. Action from this state could become extreme himsa then. However, bhrantidarshana is an inevitable part of this process. It is hence useful to be sceptical about one's own insights and treat them lightly.  They are simply signs and sights on the way. And still, perceptions of the mind.  They will pass.  It is work-in-progress.  It is all play and experiment as well. The social boundaries for compassion, peace and happiness are clear - the yamas and niyamas indicate them.  And the direction is crystal clear - As the practice matures, Intelligence acts through us4, "Tada drashtu swaroope avasthanam" (YS I.3). 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1Asmita - The identification with the "I", self construct
2YS - Yoga Sutra, the text of aphorisms on Yoga given by Patanjali 
3Sutra on viniyoga - intelligent steps, application on the path. 
4Sutra translation - Raghu Anantanarayanan